DC Comic Fan Question

Search

Rx Wizard
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,438
Tokens
Now, we all know "Gotham City" was inspired by "New York City." The parallels are unmistakable. A lot of the landmarks are the same, and indeed, New Yorkers commonly refer to their home as "Gotham."

Now, with that being said, WTF is "Metropolis?" That CAN'T also be New York City. If so, that is BOGUS. How can New York be the duel center of the DC comic book universe? Yet, the parallels are unmistakable there too. The Daily Planet is a dead ringer for the New York Post. If I am not mistaken, the Statue of Liberty and shit like that used to appear in Superman comics all the time. I remember the Chris Reeve "Superman" movie was filed entirely in NY City (the twin towers and statue of Lib appeared when Superman was flying around, and Margot Kidder's penthouse had a killer view of Manhatten).

Does anyone know WTF Metropolis was supposed to represent in the DC world?

:monsters-
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
Yes, but there is also the alternate universe theory to contend with. Which states that there are several planet earths occupied by several different heros.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
Multiverse (DC Comics)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.


<!-- start content -->In DC Comics, the Multiverse was a continuity construct in which multiple fictional versions of the universe existed in the same space, separated from each other by their vibrational resonances. Each universe in this multiverse varied from the others, in either subtle or profound ways.

In particular, the Earth of each universe had a different set of superheroes, or the life histories of its superheroes were different from those of others'. In several cases, characters from other publishers acquired by DC - previously established as a part of a fictional universe of their own - were assigned their own alternate universe within the Multiverse. The universes were identified by referring to the alternate Earths, known as "Earth-One", "Earth-Two", "Earth-Three", "Earth-X", and so forth. The first such parallel world was introduced in 1961 in The Flash #123, in the story "Flash of Two Worlds". They were eliminated in Crisis on Infinite Earths, a mini-series published in 1985.

<TABLE class=toc id=toc><TBODY><TR><TD>Contents

[hide]
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE><SCRIPT type=text/javascript>//<![CDATA[ if (window.showTocToggle) { var tocShowText = "show"; var tocHideText = "hide"; showTocToggle(); } //]]></SCRIPT>

[edit]


Earth-One

Home of DC's Silver Age heroes, including the original Justice League of America. In this world, Superman had a career as Superboy while in his teens, and an array of other superheroes first appeared in the 1950s or later. The Flash was police scientist Barry Allen, Green Lantern was galactic peacekeeper Hal Jordan, Hawkman was Thanagarian Katar Hol, and the Atom was shrinking scientist Ray Palmer. Characters unique to this world included the Martian Manhunter, Elongated Man, Firestorm, the Guardians of the Universe and Green Lantern Corps, the Teen Titans, the New Gods, and most other heroes introduced by DC in the 1960s and 1970s. As the default Earth for most of DC's comics during the prolific Multiverse era, this was by far the most "populous" and greatly explored.

[edit]


Earth-Two

Home of DC's Golden Age heroes, including the Justice Society of America. In this world, Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman began their careers as adults at the dawn of World War II (concurrent with their first appearances in comics). The Flash was chemistry student Jay Garrick, Green Lantern was magic-powered Alan Scott, Hawkman was archaeologist Carter Hall, and the Atom was pint-sized powerhouse Al Pratt. Characters unique to this world included the Star-Spangled Kid, Huntress, The Spectre, Johnny Thunder, Dr. Fate, and Mr. Terrific. The heroes of this world appeared as comic book characters on Earth-One (subconsciously channeled by Earth-One's writers).

[edit]


Earth-Three

Home of evil versions of Earth-One heroes, including the Crime Syndicate of America. In this world, history was "backwards": Christopher Columbus was an American who discovered Europe; Britain fought and won its freedom from the United States in the Revolutionary War; President John Wilkes Booth was assassinated by actor Abraham Lincoln; the United States flag had "reversed" colors (black stars on a red background, and alternating blue and black stripes); and so on. Noteworthy characters include Ultraman (Superman), Superwoman (Wonder Woman), Owlman (Batman), Power Ring (Green Lantern), Johnny Quick (Flash), and Alexander Luthor (a heroic version of Lex Luthor). This world is not to be confused with the evil world called Qward, from Green Lantern, which is the antimatter counterpart of Earth and which cannot be entered by the same means that the other Earths can.

[edit]


Earth-Four

Home of the former Charlton Comics heroes. This world was introduced at the beginning of Crisis and did not survive; several of its heroes did. Noteworthy characters include Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, Nightshade, Peacemaker, The Question, Peter Cannon, Thunderbolt, and Judomaster.

[edit]


Earth-Six

Home of Lady Quark and Lord Volt. On this Earth, America lost the Revolutionary War, and was apparently ruled by a royal family of superheroes. Given its appearance, technology seems to have progressed faster on this world as well. It was destroyed in Crisis, with only Lady Quark surviving.

[edit]


Earth-Twelve

Home of the Inferior Five. Noteworthy characters include Awkwardman, Blimp, Dumb Bunny, Merryman, and White Feather. This world may have been home to other comedic superheroes published by DC.

[edit]


Earth-A

Home of the Lawless League. This world was created by Johnny Thunder's evil counterpart from Earth-One when he altered the origins of the Justice League. "A" stood for "alternate", since it was an alternate version of Earth-One. The heroes of this world included alternate, evil versions of Superman, Batman, the Flash, Green Lantern, and the Martian Manhunter, as the evil Johnny Thunder's criminal henchmen, granted powers and skills identical to the Justice League's members.

[edit]


Earth-B

This world was never officially established, but is often cited as the setting for team-up stories told in The Brave and the Bold which did not always conform to established continuity for Earth-One (or any other established Earth). For instance, one such story featured Catwoman committing murder, which neither the Earth-One nor Earth-Two versions would ever do as it was strictly against either character's moral code. Notable characters include Batman (who appeared regularly in the series).

[edit]


Earth-C

Home of Captain Carrot and His Amazing Zoo Crew. This world is populated with anthropomorphic animals. Notable characters include the members of the Zoo Crew: Captain Carrot, Alley-Kat-Abra, Fastback, Little Cheese, Pig-Iron, Rubberduck, and Yankee Poodle.

[edit]


Earth-C-Minus

Home of the Justa Lotta Animals, this world (like Earth-C) is also populated by anthropomorphic animals. Notable characters include Super-Squirrel, Wonder Wabbit, the Batmouse, Green Lambkin, Aquaduck, and the Crash. Events and characters on this world paralleled those of Earth-One; additionally, events and characters on Earth-C-Minus existed only as fictional comics on Earth-C (in his secret identity, Capt. Carrot was the writer/artist of the "Justa Lotta Animals" comic in his world).

[edit]


Earth-D

Home of the Justice Alliance of America. This world appeared in Legends of the DC Universe as a previously-untold chapter of Crisis published more than a decade after the fact. It featured a more ethnically diverse version of several Earth-One heroes, with no major tragedies in the heroes' lives (not counting the Crisis, of course). As such it was a combination of modern multi-cultural sensibilities combined with Silver-Age-style innocence.

[edit]


Earth-Q / Earth-Quality

Home of the Freedom Fighters and Kid Eternity as they were originally published by Quality Comics in the 1940s (i.e. not the later versions published by DC, set on Earth-X and Earth-S). Not officially identified.

[edit]


Earth-S

Home of the former Fawcett Comics heroes, including Captain Marvel and the Marvel (or Shazam!) Family (Captain Marvel, Mary Marvel, Captain Marvel, Jr., and Uncle Marvel). Other noteworthy characters include Bulletman, Bulletgirl, Ibis the Invincible, Spy Smasher, Mister Scarlet and Pinky, and Commando Yank.

[edit]


Earth-X

Adopted home of several former Quality Comics heroes, including the Freedom Fighters. On this world, Nazi Germany won World War II, and the Freedom Fighters - originally from Earth-Two - fought to defeat them. Noteworthy characters include Uncle Sam, the Human Bomb, Miss America, The Ray, Black Condor, Doll Man, Phantom Lady, Firebrand, and the Red Bee.

[edit]


Earth-Prime

Home of few or no superheroes; this was supposedly "our" world, where the characters of Earth-One were merely comic book characters (the continued existence of the real world following the destruction of Earth-Prime in Crisis suggests that it was not, in fact, our world). DC editor Julius Schwartz lived here, and met the Flash of Earth-One who visited this world. The little-used character Ultraa was the first superhero to appear in this world, but after his initial adventure, he relocated to Earth-One (in light of realizing that Earth-Prime wasn't ready for superheroes). In a story just before Crisis on Infinite Earths, a young Clark Kent of this world discovered that he had super powers and became Superboy; at the climax of Crisis, he joined the Superman and Lois Lane of Earth-Two (the originals) in a kind of paradise.

[edit]


Other Earths

Various other Earths were arguably depicted in DC's substantial publishing output during the period in which the Multiverse was in effect. Identifiers such as "Earth-Five" or "Earth-K" have been coined by fans and applied to certain characters and stories. Some Earths have been posited to explain (for example) Superman Jr. and Batman Jr. (the teenage sons of the two heroes who appeared in a handful of stories and cannot be reconciled with any known Earth) or the Super Friends (based on the TV series). On yet another conjectured Earth, the Silver Age DC Comics heroes lived side-by-side with the Silver Age Marvel Comics heroes, and it is on this alternate Earth where various team-ups and battles between the two publishers' heroes have occurred over the years. Some of these could instead be categorised using the "imaginary story" identifier which DC occasionally applied to stories they didn't wish to be considered part of continuity, especially before the invention of the Multiverse.

[edit]


Contact between universes

Most inhabitants of the Multiverse were completely unaware of the other universes. The first character to cross the gap between them was Barry Allen, the Flash of Earth-One, who accidentally vibrated at just the right speed to appear on Earth-Two, where he met Jay Garrick, his Earth-Two counterpart.

Other characters with super-speed powers were able to duplicate the trick, but it was not often done. Magic and technological devices could do the job as well. The Justice League's "transmatter" device (ordinarily used to transport between their satellite headquarters and the ground), was pressed into service for annual events in which the League and some of their counterparts on other Earths faced a universe-crossing "crisis" of one sort or another. Writers occasionally put characters from different Earths together in the same story without explanation, a continuity error often cited as a reason for eliminating the Multiverse in Crisis.

[edit]


Pre-Crisis

Characters, events and other elements established before Crisis (especially those eliminated by it) are considered "Pre-Crisis", and were part of the Multiverse.

[edit]


Crisis

The Multiverse was destroyed in the "maxi-series" Crisis on Infinite Earths by a villain known as the Anti-Monitor. One by one, the Anti-Monitor invaded each universe and destroyed it. The heroes of Earth-One, Earth-Two, Earth-Four, Earth-S, and Earth-X, along with survivors from at least two other universes, managed to hold off the destruction of these last five universes long enough to defeat the Anti-Monitor. The five were merged into a single universe with its own history combining elements of the five with completely new elements. For example, there was a Flash named Jay Garrick in the JSA during the 1940s, and another Flash named Barry Allen in the JLA during the 1960s. But Superman had a completely new history, different from the Superman of Earth-One or Earth-Two. Several characters famous from Pre-Crisis works (most importantly Supergirl and Barry Allen as the Flash) were killed during Crisis, and, as a result were either erased from history (in Supergirl's case) or simply proclaimed dead in the new, singular universe.

[edit]


Post-Crisis

Some fans refused to accept that the Multiverse no longer "existed" after Crisis, and posited that the "Post-Crisis" DC Universe was merely another alternate universe within the Multiverse, sometimes dubbed "Earth-Zero" or "Earth-PC".

Although DC did not relent on their position that the other Earths no longer existed (and had "never" existed), they published occasional one-shots and mini-series labeled "Elseworlds", many of which would have been consistent with the concept of the Multiverse. But DC officially classified these are stories that perhaps "could have" happened, but had not. They maintained that there was only one canonical Earth in the DC Universe. Although never labelled as "Elseworlds" tales, Stan Lee's reimagining of DC heroes and graphic novels such as Dark Knight Returns, which diverge from established continuity, could be said to also reflect the "Elseworlds" concept.

DC relented somewhat with the introduction of Hypertime, which provided a conceptual framework to recognize both canonical and apocryphal stories. It was arguably a superset of the Multiverse, including not only the whole range of pre-Crisis stories set on alternate Earths, but any story set in any continuity.

[edit]


Representations in other media

The concept of the multiverse has been parodied in an episode of Futurama. In it, Professor Farnsworth creates an alternate universe inside a cardboard box, while at the same time, in that alternate universe, alternate-Professor Farnsworth creates our universe in a similar cardboard box. When the characters of the two universes meet, they begin to parody many of DC's multiverse conventions:

  • DC's system of naming its universes was parodied when the characters decided to name the two universes "Universe A" and "Universe 1" (with no real reason behind either name).
  • Universe 1 Professor states the "fact" that, if an alternate universe exists, it's full of nothing but evil clones (consistent with the idea of Earth-Three, as well as the science fiction cliche of alternate universes frequently only shown as being an all-evil exact "opposite" to the "real" one, akin to Star Trek's "mirror universe")
  • Besides a few differences in key colors (such as a red-haired Leela and a multi-colored sky), the two universes are exactly the same except for one thing: all coin tosses made in Universe A have the opposite outcome in Universe 1. This situation parodies DC's tendency to have universes differ based on often arbitrary circumstances.
Likewise, Bongo Comics has published a Simpsons/Futurama crossover titled "Infinitely Secret Crossover Crisis", referring to Crisis on Infinite Earths and Marvel Comics' Secret Wars. Numerous conventions of DC's multiverse are parodied, including the practice of having one universe's chracters appearing as fictional comic book characters in another. Futurama's Fry is quite fond of Simpsons comics.
 

Rx Wizard
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,438
Tokens
RobFunk, nowhere in the alternate Earths you mentioned above is "the Batman" mentioned.

Also, Batman and Superman were not "purchased" by separate publishers, but rather, both were created by DC, not too far apart.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
I know that

Metropolis is probably manhatten

and Gotham is probably the bronx or something
 
Last edited:

Rx Wizard
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,438
Tokens
Rob Funk, I just got done re-reading "The Dark Knight Returns", Frank Miller, circa 1986. In book 4, Gotham City is nuked by the Soviets, and the newscaster mentions there is also rioting in "Metropolis." Just thought you should know that. The alternate universe theory does not apply.

Clearly, DC is east coast centric. Typical nose-up arrogant bastards--think nothing else exists outside of the east coast, the east coast is the center of the world, and they therefore made it the center of the comic book universe by making two versions of New York City the homes of their two flagship heros, Bats and Superman.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
47,431
Tokens
You may be right. I really liked dark night, but if you look at 'the watchmen' which is the other landmark graphic novel they had at the time you will see that it too, has settings which closely resemble New York.

And this is partially a reason why I always favored Marvel. I really liked "west coast avengers".
 

Rx Post Doc
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
12,805
Tokens
I wish I could think of something funny to say, but I have nothing. tulsa
 

Rx Wizard
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,438
Tokens
RobFunk said:
You may be right. I really liked dark night, but if you look at 'the watchmen' which is the other landmark graphic novel they had at the time you will see that it too, has settings which closely resemble New York.

And this is partially a reason why I always favored Marvel. I really liked "west coast avengers".


Well, even Marvel was centered around NYC. Spidey, Fantastic Four, Avengers, Daredevil, etc.

Quite shameful creative thinking when you really think about it. How can one city be the home of every major superhero on earth?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,115,836
Messages
13,527,324
Members
100,329
Latest member
tiberio102
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com